Being a landlord in Orlando can be both rewarding and challenging. While most tenants follow the lease and treat your property with respect, there are times when you encounter bad tenants — those who pay rent late, damage property, or cause disturbances.
These situations can lead to financial losses, legal trouble, and unnecessary stress if not handled properly.
Whether you’re managing a single rental unit or several investment properties, knowing how to handle problem tenants professionally and effectively is essential to protecting your business.
🏠 Need expert strategies for dealing with tenant issues in Orlando?
Download our Free Orlando Landlord’s Guide to Handling Problem Tenants — packed with practical tips, legal steps, and communication templates to help you navigate difficult rental situations.
1. Identify the Type of Bad Tenant You’re Dealing With
Before taking any action, you need to determine what kind of tenant issue you’re facing. Not all problem tenants are the same, and different situations require different approaches.
Common Types of Problem Tenants:
- The Late Payer – Always behind on rent but promises to “catch up soon.”
- The Rule Breaker – Ignores lease terms, sneaks in pets, or adds unauthorized occupants.
- The Property Damager – Leaves behind holes, stains, or broken fixtures.
- The Nuisance Tenant – Causes noise complaints or conflicts with neighbors.
- The Non-Communicator – Avoids calls, emails, or written notices altogether.
By identifying which type of tenant you’re dealing with, you can tailor your response — whether it’s enforcing late fees, issuing a formal warning, or preparing for legal action.
Get Your Orlando Landlord’s Guide to Evicting Tenants!
Download our comprehensive guide, Orlando Landlord’s Guide to Evicting Tenants, and gain:
✅ Step-by-step instructions
✅ Links to essential forms and resources
✅ Pro tips for a smooth property sale
✅ Clear timelines and next steps
2. Communicate Clearly and Professionally
The first step in resolving most tenant issues is open, clear communication. Sometimes, what appears to be defiance may be a misunderstanding or temporary hardship.
Reach out to your tenant in writing to discuss the issue. Keep your tone calm and factual — not emotional. This sets the tone for a productive resolution.
Best Practices for Communication:
- Use Written Notices: Always follow up conversations with written documentation.
- Be Specific: State exactly what lease clause has been violated and the action required.
- Set Deadlines: Give clear timelines for resolving the issue.
- Stay Professional: Avoid arguments; stick to facts and lease terms.
If your tenant ignores your attempts to communicate, you may need to escalate the issue to the next level.
💡 Pro Tip: Use digital property management tools to track messages, rent payments, and maintenance requests — this creates a reliable paper trail.
📄 Want to make sure you report everything correctly? Our guide includes a tax reporting checklist. Download it free!
3. Enforce the Lease Agreement
Your lease agreement is your strongest protection as a landlord. It defines the rights and responsibilities of both you and your tenant, as well as what happens when rules are broken.
If your tenant continues to cause problems despite warnings, it’s time to enforce your lease terms. This might include:
- Charging late fees for overdue rent
- Sending a “Notice to Cure or Quit” (fix the problem or vacate)
- Pursuing eviction if the issue persists
Example:
If a tenant continually fails to pay rent on time, issue a 3-day notice to pay or vacate (as permitted under Florida law). This formal notice shows that you take the lease seriously and are prepared to act.
💡 Pro Tip: Always check Florida’s landlord-tenant laws before sending any notice. Specific timelines and procedures must be followed to ensure your notice is legally valid.
📘 Our Free Orlando Landlord’s Guide includes sample lease violation notices you can customize for your property.
4. Offer Solutions Before Taking Legal Action
While eviction may sometimes be necessary, it should be a last resort. The eviction process in Orlando can be time-consuming and costly, often taking several weeks or even months to complete.
Instead, consider alternative solutions that might resolve the issue faster — and with less expense.
Possible Alternatives:
- Payment Plan: If the tenant is struggling financially, create a short-term repayment schedule.
- Cash for Keys: Offer a small cash incentive for the tenant to vacate voluntarily and leave the property in good condition.
- Lease Termination Agreement: Allow the tenant to break the lease early without penalty if they agree to move out peacefully.
These solutions may seem generous, but they often save landlords significant money and stress compared to lengthy legal disputes.
🏡 Still weighing your options? Our guide helps you decide what’s best for you. Download it here!
5. Know When (and How) to Begin the Eviction Process
If communication fails and the tenant refuses to cooperate, eviction may be the only option left. In Florida, landlords must follow a strict legal eviction process to remove tenants lawfully.
The Florida Eviction Process at a Glance:
- Serve a Legal Notice: Depending on the violation, issue a 3-day notice to pay rent or vacate, or a 7-day notice for lease violations.
- File an Eviction Complaint: If the tenant doesn’t comply, file the case in your county court.
- Attend the Hearing: Present evidence like your lease agreement, payment records, and written notices.
- Obtain a Writ of Possession: Once approved, the sheriff will legally remove the tenant from the property.
Evictions can be stressful, but following the law protects your rights and avoids potential lawsuits for wrongful eviction.
✅ Stay ahead of tax surprises! Download our comprehensive guide. Get it now!
Bonus Tip: Prevent Bad Tenants Before They Move In
The best way to deal with bad tenants is to avoid them altogether. Strong tenant screening is your first line of defense against future problems.
Screening Checklist:
- Verify employment and income
- Check rental history and landlord references
- Run a credit and background check
- Meet the tenant in person when possible
By setting clear expectations and selecting reliable tenants upfront, you minimize the risk of late payments, property damage, and eviction headaches later.
📘 Download your Free Orlando Landlord’s Guide for customizable screening templates and interview questions.
Final Thoughts: Handling Difficult Tenants the Smart Way
Dealing with bad tenants in Orlando can be emotionally draining and financially challenging, but with the right strategies, you can regain control of your rental property and protect your investment.
Remember these five key steps:
- Identify the type of bad tenant.
- Communicate clearly and professionally.
- Enforce your lease agreement.
- Offer fair solutions before pursuing eviction.
- Follow Florida’s legal eviction process if necessary.
By staying calm, professional, and informed, you can turn even the toughest rental situations into manageable outcomes — and keep your business running smoothly.
📞 Need help handling a problem tenant in Orlando?
Download our Free Orlando Landlord’s Guide to Handling Problem Tenants for expert strategies, templates, and legal insights to protect your property today.