How To Sell a Rental Property with Tenants in Orlando

Selling a rental property in Orlando can be a complex process—especially when tenants are still living in the home. As a landlord, you need to balance protecting your tenants’ rights with ensuring a smooth and profitable sale. Remember, while you own the property, it’s also your tenants’ home. If this is your first time selling a tenant-occupied property, here’s a step-by-step guide on how to properly notify your tenants, prepare the property for listing, and close the sale with confidence.

How To Sell an Occupied House with Tenants

Selling a house with tenants can be a challenging process. It requires careful planning, communication, and cooperation to ensure that the rights of both the landlord and the tenants are protected. 

Notify Your Tenants

The first and most important step when selling a rental property with tenants is to inform them of your plans. Provide your tenants with a written notice outlining your intention to sell, including the expected listing date and when you plan to start showing the property to potential buyers. In most states, landlords are required to give at least 24 hours’ notice before any showings or inspections.

Open and honest communication is key during this process. Keep your tenants updated on any new developments—such as scheduled showings, offers, or the confirmed closing date. Being transparent helps build trust, reduces misunderstandings, and ensures a smoother experience for everyone involved.

Prepare Your Property for Sale

After notifying your tenants, the next step is to get your property ready for the market. This may involve completing necessary repairs, giving the space a deep clean, and staging it to highlight its best features. The goal is to make a strong impression on potential buyers and showcase the property’s full value.

If your tenants are still occupying the home, it’s important to respect their comfort and privacy throughout the process. Coordinate with them to schedule cleaning, maintenance, and staging at convenient times. Be considerate of their routines and try to minimize disruptions—such as avoiding showings during their work hours or family time. A cooperative and respectful approach can help maintain good relations and ensure a smoother selling experience for both you and your tenants.

Work with Your Tenants

Selling a rental property that’s still occupied requires cooperation and understanding between you and your tenants. Maintaining open communication and being flexible can make a significant difference. For instance, if your tenants feel uneasy about frequent visits from potential buyers, you might consider limiting showings or arranging them only at times that are most convenient for the tenants.

Be ready to address any questions or worries your tenants might have about the process—such as what will happen to their security deposit, how their lease will be handled, or where they’ll live after the sale. Responding to these concerns with honesty and transparency helps build trust, reduces tension, and encourages your tenants to work with you rather than against the sale.

Different Types of Leases

If you’re a landlord looking to sell your occupied rental property in Orlando, you have a few options available to you depending on the type of lease your tenants are holding. 

Tenants with Fixed Term-Leases

A fixed-term lease is a lease agreement that has a specific end date, usually six months or a year from the start of the lease. If you’re a landlord with tenants on a fixed-term lease, you have two options when it comes to selling your property.

1. Wait Until the Lease is Up to Sell

One option is to wait until the lease is up to sell the property. This is the simplest and most straightforward option, as it allows you to sell the property without disrupting your tenants’ lives. You’ll also need to make sure that you’re following the terms of your lease agreement, which may have specific provisions regarding the sale of the property.

2. List with Tenants in Place

Another option is to list the property with tenants in place. This can be a more challenging option, as it requires you to work with your tenants to ensure that the property is presentable and that showings are scheduled at convenient times. However, it can also be a more attractive option for potential buyers, as it allows them to see the property as it is currently being used. If you choose to list the property with tenants in place, it’s important to communicate with your tenants throughout the process and to be respectful of their privacy and living space. You’ll need to give your tenants ample notice before you put the property on the market. And most states require landlords to give tenants at least 24 hours notice before showing the property to potential buyers. 

One thing to keep in mind is that if you do choose to sell the property with tenants in place, you may need to offer an incentive to your tenants to ensure their cooperation. For example, you could offer a rent reduction or a cash bonus for keeping the property clean and tidy during the selling process.

3. Sell Directly to a Cash Home Buyer

If you’re looking to sell your Orlando property quickly and don’t want to deal with the hassle of listing the property or waiting for the lease to end, you could consider selling directly to a cash home buyer. Cash home buyers are investors who specialize in buying properties quickly and can offer you a cash payment for your property. This can be an attractive option for landlords who want to sell their property quickly and don’t want to deal with the hassle of listing the property or working with tenants.

However, it’s important to keep in mind that you may not get the same price for your property when selling to a cash home buyer as you would if you listed it on the open market. Cash home buyers may pay less, but buy purchasing as-is, you can save money on commissions, repairs, and holding costs. 

Tenants with Month-to-Month Leases

A month-to-month lease is a lease agreement that automatically renews each month. If you’re a landlord with tenants on a month-to-month lease, you have a few options when it comes to selling your property.

1. Renegotiate

One option is to renegotiate the lease agreement with your tenants. For example, you could offer your tenants a new lease agreement with a longer term, such as six months or a year. This would give you more time to sell the property without disrupting your tenants’ lives. It would also give your tenants more security, as they would have a longer-term lease agreement.

However, it’s important to keep in mind that your tenants may not be willing to sign a new lease agreement. They may prefer the flexibility of a month-to-month lease, and forcing them to sign a longer-term lease could cause tension in your landlord-tenant relationship.

2. Terminate

Another option is to terminate the lease agreement with your tenants. This can be a more challenging option, as it requires you to give your tenants notice that you’re terminating the lease agreement. Most states require landlords to give tenants at least 30 days’ notice before terminating a month-to-month lease.

However, if you’re looking to sell the property quickly and don’t want to deal with the hassle of working with tenants, terminating the lease agreement may be your best option. Once the lease agreement is terminated, you can sell the property without worrying about disrupting your tenants’ lives or following the terms of a lease agreement.

What to Do If Your Tenants Don’t Want to Leave

As a landlord in Orlando, you might face a difficult situation — you’re ready to sell your rental property, but your tenants aren’t ready to move out. While this can be stressful, there are several practical options available that can help you move forward smoothly and legally.

---

Option 1: Sell Directly to Your Tenant

One of the most straightforward solutions is to sell the property to your current tenant. This approach can benefit both parties — your tenant already knows the home, feels comfortable in the neighborhood, and may prefer to stay rather than move. Because of that, they might even be willing to pay a fair price to avoid the hassle of relocating.

If your tenant expresses interest in buying, start by consulting a real estate attorney to ensure the transaction follows all Orlando and Florida legal requirements. You’ll also want to have the property professionally appraised to determine its fair market value, which will help guide your negotiations.

Financing is another key factor. If your tenant can’t qualify for a traditional mortgage, you might explore owner financing, where you act as the lender and the tenant makes monthly payments directly to you. This arrangement can speed up the sale, but it’s essential to have legal safeguards in place.

Selling directly to your tenant can be an ideal outcome when both parties are willing and able to move forward. However, not every tenant will be in a financial position to buy — and in that case, other options should be considered.

---

Option 2: Sell to a Real Estate Investor

Another viable route is selling your property to a local Orlando real estate investor. Many investors are specifically looking for tenant-occupied properties because they generate immediate rental income. Since the home already has paying tenants, investors often see this as a lower-risk, ready-made investment and may offer a competitive price.

Before moving ahead, it’s smart to work with a qualified real estate agent who has experience connecting landlords with reputable investors. You’ll still need to get an accurate appraisal and negotiate a fair deal that reflects both the property’s condition and its rental potential.

However, keep in mind that not every investor will want to keep the existing tenants. Some may plan to renovate or reposition the property, meaning your tenants could eventually need to move. If that happens, make sure to follow Florida’s landlord-tenant laws by giving proper notice and maintaining open communication to ensure a smooth transition.

---

Whether you decide to sell directly to your tenant or to an investor, the key is to approach the situation with transparency, fairness, and professionalism. By doing so, you can protect your interests, minimize conflict, and successfully sell your Orlando rental property — even with tenants still in place.

Paying Your Tenant to Leave

If your tenant isn’t interested in buying the property and you can’t find an investor willing to keep them in place, another option is to offer a cash-for-keys agreement — essentially paying your tenant to move out voluntarily. While it might feel like a tough decision, this approach can help you sell your property faster and avoid the complications that often come with eviction or prolonged disputes.

Before moving forward, consult with a real estate attorney to make sure the agreement complies with Florida law and that all required paperwork and disclosures are properly handled. Negotiate a fair and reasonable amount with your tenant — enough to motivate them to leave on agreeable terms — and ensure they sign a release of liability agreement to protect you from future legal claims.

The main drawback of this option is cost. Depending on the tenant and the situation, you may need to offer a substantial amount to encourage them to move. However, in many cases, this expense is worth it to save time, prevent legal headaches, and keep the sale on track.

---

What to Do If Your Tenants Are Causing Trouble

It’s one thing for tenants to refuse to leave — but it’s another issue entirely when they start causing problems. As a landlord in Orlando, this can be one of the most stressful parts of selling a rental property. Difficult tenants might neglect the home, refuse access for showings, or create tension during the sales process.

When this happens, it’s often best to bring in professional help. You can:

• Work with a real estate agent experienced in managing properties with challenging tenants.
• Hire a property manager to handle communication, inspections, and coordination on your behalf.
• Consult a real estate attorney to understand your rights, mediate disputes, and ensure all actions remain within legal boundaries.
• Or, if you want to avoid the hassle altogether, consider selling your property directly to a local home-buying company like Orlando Cash Home Buyer, which specializes in purchasing tenant-occupied properties quickly and with minimal disruption.

A skilled attorney can also assist in resolving conflicts, negotiating with uncooperative tenants, and reviewing or drafting lease agreements that better protect your interests in future rentals.

Dealing with problematic tenants while trying to sell is never easy, but you don’t have to handle it alone. By working with the right professionals — property managers, real estate agents, investors, and attorneys — you can find a solution that protects your investment, ensures a legal sale, and keeps the process as smooth as possible for both you and your tenants.